@kaniini There are a couple of good points in here, but this is a really cynical take on AP.

I'd agree it has some blindspots that need to be addressed, but lines such as "In an ideal world, the number of ActivityPub implementations would be zero." is pure hyperbole.

Further I would give it more deference if it presented a viable option as opposed to "this is bad, but I don't know how to do it better"

We gotta do better than this if we are to push forward.

@Are0h That's part of the upcoming series. And it's kinda been hinted at on their timelines (leveraging facets of Zot's apporach, using capability URIs vs implied actions, etc) @kaniini

@jalcine Aight, cool. Hopefully will get better because this isn't a great start.

There are some salient points about security that I absolutely agree with, but most of it just seems like editorializing.

I'd rather see problems identified and then explorations of possible ways to improve.

But I guess they're saving that for later. I hope.

@kaniini

@Are0h @kaniini @jalcine

well, this was meant to be kind of an explanatory post of what my present world view is on activitypub, having spent a year basically bringing up an AP implementation from scratch, and working in a codebase which built on AS2 with some elements of AP as a data model.

so it basically *is* editorializing on the topic.

the next blog post in that series that i'm working out in my head actually has to do with what a merged AP + Zot6 type protocol might look like, and what is good and bad about that. it will also attempt to explain in detail why tying personal identity and cryptographic tokens together is fundamentally unwise (although my post about Blind Key Rotation went into some explanation on why that is unwise too), and introduce a construction of capability URIs and proof responses as an alternative.
Follow

@kaniini @kaniini@blog.dereferenced.org @Are0h @jalcine Wow, I read about Zot6 yesterday in a wikipedia comparison and on the official webpage and repository of osada jajajajaja

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Melalandia

Free Mastodon instance as in freedom.